A new assessment model for tumor heterogeneity analysis with F-FDG PET images
Wang, Ping; Xu, Wengui; Sun, Jian; Yang, Chengwen; Wang, Gang; Sa, Yu; Hu, Xin-Hua; Feng, Yuanming
It has been shown that the intratumor heterogeneity can be characterized with quantitative analysis of the F-FDG PET image data. The existing models employ multiple parameters for feature extraction which makes it difficult to implement in clinical settings for the quantitative characterization. This article reports an easy-to-use and differential SUV based model for quantitative assessment of the intratumor heterogeneity from 3D F-FDG PET image data. An H index is defined to assess tumor heterogeneity by summing voxel-wise distribution of differential SUV from the F-FDG PET image data. The summation is weighted by the distance of SUV difference among neighboring voxels from the center of the tumor and can thus yield increased values for tumors with peripheral sub-regions of high SUV that often serves as an indicator of augmented malignancy. Furthermore, the sign of H index is used to differentiate the rate of change for volume averaged SUV from its center to periphery. The new model with the H index has been compared with a widely-used model of gray level co-occurrence matrix (GLCM) for image texture characterization with phantoms of different configurations and the F-FDG PET image data of 6 lung cancer patients to evaluate its effectiveness and feasibility for clinical uses. The comparison of the H index and GLCM parameters with the phantoms demonstrate that the H index can characterize the SUV heterogeneity in all of 6 2D phantoms while only 1 GLCM parameter can do for 1 and fail to differentiate for other 2D phantoms. For the 8 3D phantoms, the H index can clearly differentiate all of them while the 4 GLCM parameters provide complicated patterns in the characterization. Feasibility study with the PET image data from 6 lung cancer patients show that the H index provides an effective single-parameter metric to characterize tumor heterogeneity in terms of the local SUV variation, and it has higher correlation with tumor volume change after radiotherapy (R2 = 0.83) than the 4 GLCM parameters (R2 = 0.63, 0.73, 0.59 and 0.75 for Energy, Contrast, Local Homogeneity and Entropy respectively). The new model of the H index has the capacity to characterize the intratumor heterogeneity feature from 3D F-FDG PET image data. As a single parameter with an intuitive definition, the H index offers potential for clinical applications.
Wang, Ping, & Xu, Wengui, & Sun, Jian, & Yang, Chengwen, & Wang, Gang, & Sa, Yu, & Hu, Xin-Hua, & Feng, Yuanming. (January 2016). A new assessment model for tumor heterogeneity analysis with F-FDG PET images. EXCLI Journal, 15(), 75- 84. Retrieved from http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5770
Wang, Ping, and Xu, Wengui, and Sun, Jian, and Yang, Chengwen, and Wang, Gang, and Sa, Yu, and Hu, Xin-Hua, and Feng, Yuanming. "A new assessment model for tumor heterogeneity analysis with F-FDG PET images". EXCLI Journal. 15:. (75-84), January 2016. April 24, 2019. http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5770.
Wang, Ping and Xu, Wengui and Sun, Jian and Yang, Chengwen and Wang, Gang and Sa, Yu and Hu, Xin-Hua and Feng, Yuanming, "A new assessment model for tumor heterogeneity analysis with F-FDG PET images," EXCLI Journal 15, no. (January 2016), http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5770 (accessed April 24, 2019).
Wang, Ping, Xu, Wengui, Sun, Jian, Yang, Chengwen, Wang, Gang, Sa, Yu, Hu, Xin-Hua, Feng, Yuanming. A new assessment model for tumor heterogeneity analysis with F-FDG PET images. EXCLI Journal. January 2016; 15(): 75-84. http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5770. Accessed April 24, 2019.