The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization
Author
Sadd, Ben M.; Barribeau, Seth M.; Bloch, Guy; de Graaf, Dirk C.; Dearden, Peter; Elsik, Christine G.; Gadau, Jürgen; Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis J.; Hasselmann, Martin; Lozier, Jeffrey D.; Robertson, Hugh M.; Smagghe, Guy; Stolle, Eckart; Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias; Waterhouse, Robert M.; Bornberg-Bauer, Erich; Klasberg, Steffen; Bennett, Anna K.; Câmara, Francisco; Guigó, Roderic; Hoff, Katharina; Mariotti, Marco; Munoz-Torres, Monica; Murphy, Terence; Santesmasses, Didac; Amdam, Gro V.; Beckers, Matthew; Beye, Martin; Biewer, Matthias; Bitondi, Márcia M.; Blaxter, Mark L.; Bourke, Andrew F.; Brown, Mark J. F.; Buechel, Severine D.; Cameron, Rossanah; Cappelle, Kaat; Carolan, James C.; Christiaens, Olivier; Ciborowski, Kate L.; Clarke, David F.; Colgan, Thomas J.; Collins, David H.; Cridge, Andrew G.; Dalmay, Tamas; Dreier, Stephanie; du Plessis, Louis; Duncan, Elizabeth; Erler, Silvio; Evans, Jay D.; Falcon, Tiago; Flores, Kevin; Freitas, Flávia C.; Fuchikawa, Taro; Gempe, Tanja; Hartfelder, Klaus; Hauser, Frank; Helbing, Sophie; Humann, Fernanda C.; Irvine, Frano; Jermiin, Lars S.; Johnson, Claire E.; Johnson, Reed M.; Jones, Andrew K; Kadowaki, Tatsuhiko; Kidner, Jonathan H.; Koch, Vasco; Köhler, Arian; Kraus, F. B.; Lattorff, H. M. G.; Leask, Megan; Lockett, Gabrielle A.; Mallon, Eamonn B.; Antonio, David S. Marco; Marxer, Monika; Meeus, Ivan; Moritz, Robin F.; Nair, Ajay; Näpflin, Kathrin; Nissen, Inga; Niu, Jinzhi; Nunes, Francis M.; Oakeshott, John G.; Osborne, Amy; Otte, Marianne; Pinheiro, Daniel G.; Rossié, Nina; Rueppell, Olav; Santos, Carolina G.; Schmid-Hempel, Regula; Schmitt, Björn D.; Schulte, Christina; Simões, Zilá L.; Soares, Michelle P.; Swevers, Luc; Winnebeck, Eva C.; Wolschin, Florian; Yu, Na; Zdobnov, Evgeny M.; Aqrawi, Peshtewani K.; Blankenburg, Kerstin P.; Coyle, Marcus; Francisco, Liezl; Hernandez, Alvaro G.; Holder, Michael; Hudson, Matthew E.; Jackson, LaRonda; Jayaseelan, Joy; Joshi, Vandita; Kovar, Christie; Lee, Sandra L.; Mata, Robert; Mathew, Tittu; Newsham, Irene F.; Ngo, Robin; Okwuonu, Geoffrey; Pham, Christopher; Pu, Ling-Ling; Saada, Nehad; Santibanez, Jireh; Simmons, DeNard; Thornton, Rebecca; Venkat, Aarti; Walden, Kimberly K.; Wu, Yuan-Qing; Debyser, Griet; Devreese, Bart; Asher, Claire; Blommaert, Julie; Chipman, Ariel D.; Chittka, Lars; Fouks, Bertrand; Liu, Jisheng; O’Neill, Meaghan P.; Sumner, Seirian; Puiu, Daniela; Qu, Jiaxin; Salzberg, Steven L.; Scherer, Steven E.; Muzny, Donna M.; Richards, Stephen; Robinson, Gene E.; Gibbs, Richard A.; Schmid-Hempel, Paul; Worley, Kim C.
Abstract
Background
The shift from solitary to social behavior is one of the major evolutionary transitions. Primitively eusocial bumblebees are uniquely placed to illuminate the evolution of highly eusocial insect societies. Bumblebees are also invaluable natural and agricultural pollinators, and there is widespread concern over recent population declines in some species. High-quality genomic data will inform key aspects of bumblebee biology, including susceptibility to implicated population viability threats.
Results
We report the high quality draft genome sequences of Bombus terrestris and Bombus impatiens, two ecologically dominant bumblebees and widely utilized study species. Comparing these new genomes to those of the highly eusocial honeybee Apis mellifera and other Hymenoptera, we identify deeply conserved similarities, as well as novelties key to the biology of these organisms. Some honeybee genome features thought to underpin advanced eusociality are also present in bumblebees, indicating an earlier evolution in the bee lineage. Xenobiotic detoxification and immune genes are similarly depauperate in bumblebees and honeybees, and multiple categories of genes linked to social organization, including development and behavior, show high conservation. Key differences identified include a bias in bumblebee chemoreception towards gustation from olfaction, and striking differences in microRNAs, potentially responsible for gene regulation underlying social and other traits.
Conclusions
These two bumblebee genomes provide a foundation for post-genomic research on these key pollinators and insect societies. Overall, gene repertoires suggest that the route to advanced eusociality in bees was mediated by many small changes in many genes and processes, and not by notable expansion or depauperation.
Subject
Date
2015-04-24
Citation:
APA:
Sadd, Ben M., & Barribeau, Seth M., & Bloch, Guy, & de Graaf, Dirk C., & Dearden, Peter, & Elsik, Christine G., & Gadau, Jürgen, & Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis J., & Hasselmann, Martin, & Lozier, Jeffrey D., & Robertson, Hugh M., & Smagghe, Guy, & Stolle, Eckart, & Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias, & Waterhouse, Robert M., & Bornberg-Bauer, Erich, & Klasberg, Steffen, & Bennett, Anna K., & Câmara, Francisco, & Guigó, Roderic, & Hoff, Katharina, & Mariotti, Marco, & Munoz-Torres, Monica, & Murphy, Terence, & Santesmasses, Didac, & Amdam, Gro V., & Beckers, Matthew, & Beye, Martin, & Biewer, Matthias, & Bitondi, Márcia M., & Blaxter, Mark L., & Bourke, Andrew F., & Brown, Mark J. F., & Buechel, Severine D., & Cameron, Rossanah, & Cappelle, Kaat, & Carolan, James C., & Christiaens, Olivier, & Ciborowski, Kate L., & Clarke, David F., & Colgan, Thomas J., & Collins, David H., & Cridge, Andrew G., & Dalmay, Tamas, & Dreier, Stephanie, & du Plessis, Louis, & Duncan, Elizabeth, & Erler, Silvio, & Evans, Jay D., & Falcon, Tiago, & Flores, Kevin, & Freitas, Flávia C., & Fuchikawa, Taro, & Gempe, Tanja, & Hartfelder, Klaus, & Hauser, Frank, & Helbing, Sophie, & Humann, Fernanda C., & Irvine, Frano, & Jermiin, Lars S., & Johnson, Claire E., & Johnson, Reed M., & Jones, Andrew K, & Kadowaki, Tatsuhiko, & Kidner, Jonathan H., & Koch, Vasco, & Köhler, Arian, & Kraus, F. B., & Lattorff, H. M. G., & Leask, Megan, & Lockett, Gabrielle A., & Mallon, Eamonn B., & Antonio, David S. Marco, & Marxer, Monika, & Meeus, Ivan, & Moritz, Robin F., & Nair, Ajay, & Näpflin, Kathrin, & Nissen, Inga, & Niu, Jinzhi, & Nunes, Francis M., & Oakeshott, John G., & Osborne, Amy, & Otte, Marianne, & Pinheiro, Daniel G., & Rossié, Nina, & Rueppell, Olav, & Santos, Carolina G., & Schmid-Hempel, Regula, & Schmitt, Björn D., & Schulte, Christina, & Simões, Zilá L., & Soares, Michelle P., & Swevers, Luc, & Winnebeck, Eva C., & Wolschin, Florian, & Yu, Na, & Zdobnov, Evgeny M., & Aqrawi, Peshtewani K., & Blankenburg, Kerstin P., & Coyle, Marcus, & Francisco, Liezl, & Hernandez, Alvaro G., & Holder, Michael, & Hudson, Matthew E., & Jackson, LaRonda, & Jayaseelan, Joy, & Joshi, Vandita, & Kovar, Christie, & Lee, Sandra L., & Mata, Robert, & Mathew, Tittu, & Newsham, Irene F., & Ngo, Robin, & Okwuonu, Geoffrey, & Pham, Christopher, & Pu, Ling-Ling, & Saada, Nehad, & Santibanez, Jireh, & Simmons, DeNard, & Thornton, Rebecca, & Venkat, Aarti, & Walden, Kimberly K., & Wu, Yuan-Qing, & Debyser, Griet, & Devreese, Bart, & Asher, Claire, & Blommaert, Julie, & Chipman, Ariel D., & Chittka, Lars, & Fouks, Bertrand, & Liu, Jisheng, & O’Neill, Meaghan P., & Sumner, Seirian, & Puiu, Daniela, & Qu, Jiaxin, & Salzberg, Steven L., & Scherer, Steven E., & Muzny, Donna M., & Richards, Stephen, & Robinson, Gene E., & Gibbs, Richard A., & Schmid-Hempel, Paul, & Worley, Kim C.. (April 2015).
The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization.
Genome Biology. 2015 Apr 24,
(),
-
. Retrieved from
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13059-015-0623-3http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5207
MLA:
Sadd, Ben M., and Barribeau, Seth M., and Bloch, Guy, and de Graaf, Dirk C., and Dearden, Peter, and Elsik, Christine G., and Gadau, Jürgen, and Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis J., and Hasselmann, Martin, and Lozier, Jeffrey D., and Robertson, Hugh M., and Smagghe, Guy, and Stolle, Eckart, and Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias, and Waterhouse, Robert M., and Bornberg-Bauer, Erich, and Klasberg, Steffen, and Bennett, Anna K., and Câmara, Francisco, and Guigó, Roderic, and Hoff, Katharina, and Mariotti, Marco, and Munoz-Torres, Monica, and Murphy, Terence, and Santesmasses, Didac, and Amdam, Gro V., and Beckers, Matthew, and Beye, Martin, and Biewer, Matthias, and Bitondi, Márcia M., and Blaxter, Mark L., and Bourke, Andrew F., and Brown, Mark J. F., and Buechel, Severine D., and Cameron, Rossanah, and Cappelle, Kaat, and Carolan, James C., and Christiaens, Olivier, and Ciborowski, Kate L., and Clarke, David F., and Colgan, Thomas J., and Collins, David H., and Cridge, Andrew G., and Dalmay, Tamas, and Dreier, Stephanie, and du Plessis, Louis, and Duncan, Elizabeth, and Erler, Silvio, and Evans, Jay D., and Falcon, Tiago, and Flores, Kevin, and Freitas, Flávia C., and Fuchikawa, Taro, and Gempe, Tanja, and Hartfelder, Klaus, and Hauser, Frank, and Helbing, Sophie, and Humann, Fernanda C., and Irvine, Frano, and Jermiin, Lars S., and Johnson, Claire E., and Johnson, Reed M., and Jones, Andrew K, and Kadowaki, Tatsuhiko, and Kidner, Jonathan H., and Koch, Vasco, and Köhler, Arian, and Kraus, F. B., and Lattorff, H. M. G., and Leask, Megan, and Lockett, Gabrielle A., and Mallon, Eamonn B., and Antonio, David S. Marco, and Marxer, Monika, and Meeus, Ivan, and Moritz, Robin F., and Nair, Ajay, and Näpflin, Kathrin, and Nissen, Inga, and Niu, Jinzhi, and Nunes, Francis M., and Oakeshott, John G., and Osborne, Amy, and Otte, Marianne, and Pinheiro, Daniel G., and Rossié, Nina, and Rueppell, Olav, and Santos, Carolina G., and Schmid-Hempel, Regula, and Schmitt, Björn D., and Schulte, Christina, and Simões, Zilá L., and Soares, Michelle P., and Swevers, Luc, and Winnebeck, Eva C., and Wolschin, Florian, and Yu, Na, and Zdobnov, Evgeny M., and Aqrawi, Peshtewani K., and Blankenburg, Kerstin P., and Coyle, Marcus, and Francisco, Liezl, and Hernandez, Alvaro G., and Holder, Michael, and Hudson, Matthew E., and Jackson, LaRonda, and Jayaseelan, Joy, and Joshi, Vandita, and Kovar, Christie, and Lee, Sandra L., and Mata, Robert, and Mathew, Tittu, and Newsham, Irene F., and Ngo, Robin, and Okwuonu, Geoffrey, and Pham, Christopher, and Pu, Ling-Ling, and Saada, Nehad, and Santibanez, Jireh, and Simmons, DeNard, and Thornton, Rebecca, and Venkat, Aarti, and Walden, Kimberly K., and Wu, Yuan-Qing, and Debyser, Griet, and Devreese, Bart, and Asher, Claire, and Blommaert, Julie, and Chipman, Ariel D., and Chittka, Lars, and Fouks, Bertrand, and Liu, Jisheng, and O’Neill, Meaghan P., and Sumner, Seirian, and Puiu, Daniela, and Qu, Jiaxin, and Salzberg, Steven L., and Scherer, Steven E., and Muzny, Donna M., and Richards, Stephen, and Robinson, Gene E., and Gibbs, Richard A., and Schmid-Hempel, Paul, and Worley, Kim C..
"The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization". Genome Biology. 2015 Apr 24.
. (),
April 2015.
September 28, 2023.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13059-015-0623-3http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5207.
Chicago:
Sadd, Ben M. and Barribeau, Seth M. and Bloch, Guy and de Graaf, Dirk C. and Dearden, Peter and Elsik, Christine G. and Gadau, Jürgen and Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis J. and Hasselmann, Martin and Lozier, Jeffrey D. and Robertson, Hugh M. and Smagghe, Guy and Stolle, Eckart and Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias and Waterhouse, Robert M. and Bornberg-Bauer, Erich and Klasberg, Steffen and Bennett, Anna K. and Câmara, Francisco and Guigó, Roderic and Hoff, Katharina and Mariotti, Marco and Munoz-Torres, Monica and Murphy, Terence and Santesmasses, Didac and Amdam, Gro V. and Beckers, Matthew and Beye, Martin and Biewer, Matthias and Bitondi, Márcia M. and Blaxter, Mark L. and Bourke, Andrew F. and Brown, Mark J. F. and Buechel, Severine D. and Cameron, Rossanah and Cappelle, Kaat and Carolan, James C. and Christiaens, Olivier and Ciborowski, Kate L. and Clarke, David F. and Colgan, Thomas J. and Collins, David H. and Cridge, Andrew G. and Dalmay, Tamas and Dreier, Stephanie and du Plessis, Louis and Duncan, Elizabeth and Erler, Silvio and Evans, Jay D. and Falcon, Tiago and Flores, Kevin and Freitas, Flávia C. and Fuchikawa, Taro and Gempe, Tanja and Hartfelder, Klaus and Hauser, Frank and Helbing, Sophie and Humann, Fernanda C. and Irvine, Frano and Jermiin, Lars S. and Johnson, Claire E. and Johnson, Reed M. and Jones, Andrew K and Kadowaki, Tatsuhiko and Kidner, Jonathan H. and Koch, Vasco and Köhler, Arian and Kraus, F. B. and Lattorff, H. M. G. and Leask, Megan and Lockett, Gabrielle A. and Mallon, Eamonn B. and Antonio, David S. Marco and Marxer, Monika and Meeus, Ivan and Moritz, Robin F. and Nair, Ajay and Näpflin, Kathrin and Nissen, Inga and Niu, Jinzhi and Nunes, Francis M. and Oakeshott, John G. and Osborne, Amy and Otte, Marianne and Pinheiro, Daniel G. and Rossié, Nina and Rueppell, Olav and Santos, Carolina G. and Schmid-Hempel, Regula and Schmitt, Björn D. and Schulte, Christina and Simões, Zilá L. and Soares, Michelle P. and Swevers, Luc and Winnebeck, Eva C. and Wolschin, Florian and Yu, Na and Zdobnov, Evgeny M. and Aqrawi, Peshtewani K. and Blankenburg, Kerstin P. and Coyle, Marcus and Francisco, Liezl and Hernandez, Alvaro G. and Holder, Michael and Hudson, Matthew E. and Jackson, LaRonda and Jayaseelan, Joy and Joshi, Vandita and Kovar, Christie and Lee, Sandra L. and Mata, Robert and Mathew, Tittu and Newsham, Irene F. and Ngo, Robin and Okwuonu, Geoffrey and Pham, Christopher and Pu, Ling-Ling and Saada, Nehad and Santibanez, Jireh and Simmons, DeNard and Thornton, Rebecca and Venkat, Aarti and Walden, Kimberly K. and Wu, Yuan-Qing and Debyser, Griet and Devreese, Bart and Asher, Claire and Blommaert, Julie and Chipman, Ariel D. and Chittka, Lars and Fouks, Bertrand and Liu, Jisheng and O’Neill, Meaghan P. and Sumner, Seirian and Puiu, Daniela and Qu, Jiaxin and Salzberg, Steven L. and Scherer, Steven E. and Muzny, Donna M. and Richards, Stephen and Robinson, Gene E. and Gibbs, Richard A. and Schmid-Hempel, Paul and Worley, Kim C.,
"The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization," Genome Biology. 2015 Apr 24 , no.
(April 2015),
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13059-015-0623-3http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5207 (accessed
September 28, 2023).
AMA:
Sadd, Ben M., Barribeau, Seth M., Bloch, Guy, de Graaf, Dirk C., Dearden, Peter, Elsik, Christine G., Gadau, Jürgen, Grimmelikhuijzen, Cornelis J., Hasselmann, Martin, Lozier, Jeffrey D., Robertson, Hugh M., Smagghe, Guy, Stolle, Eckart, Van Vaerenbergh, Matthias, Waterhouse, Robert M., Bornberg-Bauer, Erich, Klasberg, Steffen, Bennett, Anna K., Câmara, Francisco, Guigó, Roderic, Hoff, Katharina, Mariotti, Marco, Munoz-Torres, Monica, Murphy, Terence, Santesmasses, Didac, Amdam, Gro V., Beckers, Matthew, Beye, Martin, Biewer, Matthias, Bitondi, Márcia M., Blaxter, Mark L., Bourke, Andrew F., Brown, Mark J. F., Buechel, Severine D., Cameron, Rossanah, Cappelle, Kaat, Carolan, James C., Christiaens, Olivier, Ciborowski, Kate L., Clarke, David F., Colgan, Thomas J., Collins, David H., Cridge, Andrew G., Dalmay, Tamas, Dreier, Stephanie, du Plessis, Louis, Duncan, Elizabeth, Erler, Silvio, Evans, Jay D., Falcon, Tiago, Flores, Kevin, Freitas, Flávia C., Fuchikawa, Taro, Gempe, Tanja, Hartfelder, Klaus, Hauser, Frank, Helbing, Sophie, Humann, Fernanda C., Irvine, Frano, Jermiin, Lars S., Johnson, Claire E., Johnson, Reed M., Jones, Andrew K, Kadowaki, Tatsuhiko, Kidner, Jonathan H., Koch, Vasco, Köhler, Arian, Kraus, F. B., Lattorff, H. M. G., Leask, Megan, Lockett, Gabrielle A., Mallon, Eamonn B., Antonio, David S. Marco, Marxer, Monika, Meeus, Ivan, Moritz, Robin F., Nair, Ajay, Näpflin, Kathrin, Nissen, Inga, Niu, Jinzhi, Nunes, Francis M., Oakeshott, John G., Osborne, Amy, Otte, Marianne, Pinheiro, Daniel G., Rossié, Nina, Rueppell, Olav, Santos, Carolina G., Schmid-Hempel, Regula, Schmitt, Björn D., Schulte, Christina, Simões, Zilá L., Soares, Michelle P., Swevers, Luc, Winnebeck, Eva C., Wolschin, Florian, Yu, Na, Zdobnov, Evgeny M., Aqrawi, Peshtewani K., Blankenburg, Kerstin P., Coyle, Marcus, Francisco, Liezl, Hernandez, Alvaro G., Holder, Michael, Hudson, Matthew E., Jackson, LaRonda, Jayaseelan, Joy, Joshi, Vandita, Kovar, Christie, Lee, Sandra L., Mata, Robert, Mathew, Tittu, Newsham, Irene F., Ngo, Robin, Okwuonu, Geoffrey, Pham, Christopher, Pu, Ling-Ling, Saada, Nehad, Santibanez, Jireh, Simmons, DeNard, Thornton, Rebecca, Venkat, Aarti, Walden, Kimberly K., Wu, Yuan-Qing, Debyser, Griet, Devreese, Bart, Asher, Claire, Blommaert, Julie, Chipman, Ariel D., Chittka, Lars, Fouks, Bertrand, Liu, Jisheng, O’Neill, Meaghan P., Sumner, Seirian, Puiu, Daniela, Qu, Jiaxin, Salzberg, Steven L., Scherer, Steven E., Muzny, Donna M., Richards, Stephen, Robinson, Gene E., Gibbs, Richard A., Schmid-Hempel, Paul, Worley, Kim C..
The genomes of two key bumblebee species with primitive eusocial organization. Genome Biology. 2015 Apr 24.
April 2015;
():
.
http://dx.doi.org/10.1186/s13059-015-0623-3http://hdl.handle.net/10342/5207. Accessed
September 28, 2023.
Collections